Closing summary
We are closing the UK politics blog. Here is a summary of events today:
Foreign secretary David Lammy criticised Russia for having “learned nothing” over the Ukraine war. In a speech at the G20 Foreign Ministerial Meeting in South Africa, he added: “We are at a crucial juncture in this conflict, and Russia faces a test”. He said the only “just and lasting peace” will be a peace “consistent with the UN charter” which “rejects Tsarist imperialism”.
Keir Starmer spoke to Volodymyr Zelenskyy to express support for him “as Ukraine’s democratically elected leader” after US president Donald Trump claimed Ukraine’s president was a “dictator”
The UK signed a defence agreement with Norway, aimed at what the countries perceive as a threat from Russia in the Arctic. Defence secretary John Healey said Norway and the UK will “step up further” support to Ukraine. At a press conference, he said Russia’s threat to Europe stretches beyond its war in Ukraine adding that Britain will support Ukraine on the “battlefield and the negotiating table”. He hailed Vlodomyr Zelenskyy’s “commitment” to his country but added that talks about peacekeeping forces were “jumping ahead of ourselves”.
On Thursday morning culture secretary Lisa Nandy said that the “heat” needed to be taken out of public discussions about any peace deal in Ukraine. She added that “it’s important that we maintain a dialogue with Russia, and I think it’s important that Russia hears what the world believes, and certainly across Europe.”
Shadow foreign secretary Priti Patel said on Thursday that she could not comment on the motivation behind Trump’s attack on Zelenskyy and that “there are no clear solutions right now”, offering tentative Conservative support to any plans to put British troops on the ground in Ukraine.
Reform UK leader Nigel Farage broke his silence on Donald Trump’s comments on Volodymyr Zelenskyy, saying: “Let’s be clear, Zelenskyy is not a dictator, but it’s only right and proper that Ukrainians have a timeline for elections.” Speaking to GB News, he said that Trump’s words should be taken “seriously” but not “literally”. He attacked people suggesting that the UK did not hold elections during the second world war, and said it was “about time the British media woke up to the truth of that.”
Nigel Farage has declared he has handed over Reform UK to its 200,000 members, but the party now appears to be owned by a not-for-profit company controlled by its leader and chair.
Former chair of the defence select committee Tobias Ellwood has warned the Britain risks being in direct conflict with Russia within five years, and said that current discussions about possible peace in Ukraine had descended into what he called “foghorn diplomacy”.
The Labour government has announced a £270m Arts Everywhere fund for arts venues, museums, libraries and the heritage sector.
Plans by the Labour government to prevent refugees who arrive in the UK on a small boat, lorry or via other so-called “irregular” means from becoming a British citizen face their first legal challenge.
Culture secretary Lisa Nandy says she will be “discussing” a Gaza documentary with the BBC after it emerged the film’s narrator was the son of a Hamas deputy minister.
Local authorities in Scotland will need to increase council tax bills by almost a fifth if they are to keep pace with increases to local government funding in England, a thinktank has found. A report from the Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS) noted “core spending power” for local government and schools in England is set to increase by 7.4% in real-terms between 2023-24 and 2025-26.
The number of number of people in hospital in England with norovirus has jumped sharply to reach a new high for this winter, NHS figures show.
The former head of the Foreign Office, Simon McDonald, has warned Rachel Reeves not to cut Britain’s international aid spending, amid signs the chancellor is willing to raid the development budget to help pay for higher defence spending.
On the Israel-Gaza war, Lammy said there needed to be a “long-term plan for security and governance on the strip” to lead to a two-state solution:
And as we turn to the Middle East, the ceasefire in Gaza is painfully fragile, I’m grateful that so many of us here today are working together to ensure that it holds we must continue to work together tirelessly to secure the release of the remaining hostages, to bolster the Palestinian Authority, and to boost aid into Gaza and to develop a long term plan for governance and security on the strip so that we can advance towards a two state solution, which remains the only long term viable pathway to peace.
David Lammy: 'Russia has learned nothing'
Foreign secretary David Lammy has been speaking at the G20 foreign ministerial meeting in South Africa.
Referring to the Ukraine war, he criticised Russia for having “learned nothing”, adding: “we are at a crucial juncture in this conflict, and Russia faces a test”.
He said that the only “just and lasting peace” will be a peace “consistent with the UN charter” which “rejects Tsarist imperialism”.
Lammy was also critical of Russian minister for foreign affairs [Sergei] Lavrov for his “logic of imperialism dressed up as realpolitik”.
He said:
You know, mature countries learn from their colonial failures and their wars, and Europeans have had much to learn over the generations and the centuries.
But I’m afraid to say that Russia has learned nothing.
I listened carefully to minister Lavrov’s intervention just now – he’s, of course, left his seat – hoping to hear some readiness to respect Ukraine’s sovereignty.
I was hoping to hear some sympathy for the innocent victims of the aggression.
I was hoping to hear some readiness to seek a durable peace.
What I heard was the logic of imperialism dressed up as a realpolitik, and I say to you all, we should not be surprised, but neither should we be fooled.
We are at a crucial juncture in this conflict, and Russia faces a test.
If Putin is serious about a lasting peace, it means finding a way forward which respects Ukraine’s sovereignty and the UN Charter which provides credible security guarantees, and which rejects Tsarist imperialism, and Britain is ready to listen.
But we expect to hear more than the Russian gentleman’s tired fabrications.
The chancellor has said no one should be in any doubt about the government’s commitment to spend 2.5% of GDP on defence.
Speaking to broadcasters at Warner Bros studios near Watford, she said:
I am absolutely committed to spending 2.5% of GDP on defence.
I’m really clear that a strong economy depends on strong defences and our national security being protected, so we will set out that pathway to 2.5% of GDP.
We will do it in the proper way, but no one should be in any doubt about my commitment to spend 2.5% of GDP on defence.
She also said she wants to create “a culture... of retail investing” to achieve “better returns for savers” in the UK amid reports she is considering cutting the limit on tax-free ISA savings.
Asked about the reports, Reeves told broadcasters:
It’s really important that we support people to save to achieve their aspirations.
At the moment, there is a £20,000 limit on what you can put into either cash or equities (ISAs) but we want to get that balance right.
I do want to create more of a culture in the UK of retail investing like what you have in the United States, to earn better returns for savers.
Not-for-profit appears to own Reform UK despite Farage’s ‘democratisation’ pledge
Nigel Farage has declared he has handed over Reform UK to its 200,000 members, but the party now appears to be owned by a not-for-profit company controlled by its leader and chair.
Farage announced last year that he would “democratise” the party after receiving criticism for it being a private company majority controlled by the leader, not a members’ association like other parties.
The company that owns Reform now appears to be owned by a new not-for-profit company, Reform 2025, which so far has just two members and two directors: Farage and Zia Yusuf.
It was previously owned by a limited company majority controlled by Farage but with stakes also held by Yusuf, Richard Tice, the deputy leader, and Mehrtash A’zami, the party secretary.
It is understood this is the permanent new structure of Reform and that Farage and Yusuf are guarantors for the company, and would be replaced if new people took on those roles. The party’s filings to Companies House says there is no person in overall control.
You can read the full report here:
At the press conference in Norway, Healey was asked, following comments by Donald Trump, whether it could be trusted that the US still has Europe’s best security interests at heart.
He said:
Europe’s best security interests and America’s best security interests are satisfied by an end to this war in Ukraine and by a strong, unified Nato.
That’s an argument that we are having and have discussed with the Americans and will continue to make.
Healey said that he had seen Ukrainian leader Mr Zelenskyy’s “commitment to his country”.
He later added:
This was a man who, stuck in his country, led his country, and still does. He was elected.
He’s the elected leader of Ukraine, and he’s done what Winston Churchill did in Britain in the Second World War, suspended elections while at war.
And our job is to stand with the Ukrainians, support the Ukrainians, support them in their fight.
And if they choose to talk, support them in the negotiations as well.
Britain will support Ukraine on the 'battlefield and the negotiating table' - John Healey
We have more from PA Media from the defence secretary, John Healey, in Norway.
Healey said that Britain will support Ukraine on the “battlefield and the negotiating table”.
But said talks about peacekeeping forces were “jumping ahead of ourselves”, PA Media reports.
Formal negotiations were still yet to start, he said, despite initial talks between the US and Russia taking place. He repeated that Ukraine needed to be involved in final talks.
He said:
In many ways we’re jumping ahead of ourselves. Our prime minister had made the commitment that if we reach a ceasefire, we reach an end to the fighting, security guarantees will be needed and Britain is ready to play a full part in that and we’re leading some of the detailed discussions about what may be needed, but I am certainly not going to give you any detail that is going to make president Putin the wiser.
He added:
Fundamentally though, the war is still being fought. Russia is still bombing, firing on, launching drones, not just on Ukrainian troops but on Ukrainian cities.
The Ukrainians are still fighting and our job is to support them in that fight, to keep them as strong as they can be when they come to the negotiating table. Support them on the battlefield, support them at the negotiating table when they choose to do so.
Updated
Russia’s threat to Europe stretches beyond its war in Ukraine - John Healey
More from the press conference earlier with defence secretary John Healey.
Russia’s threat to Europe stretches beyond its war in Ukraine, John Healey said.
The defence secretary said the reason for his visit to Norway, during which he met with his Norwegian counterpart Tore Sandvik, was to present a united front against Vladimir Putin’s forces.
He said:
One of the reasons that I wanted to join Tore here in Norway was also to remind people that we look at the Russian war in Ukraine, but Russia remains a threat beyond Ukraine, and Russia’s aggression is not confined to Ukraine and we have to meet that challenge and confront that together.
UK and Norway 'will step up further the support we give to Ukraine' - John Healey
We have more on defence secretary John Healey speaking about the UK’s defence agreement with Norway.
Discussing the declaration that both countries have signed, Mr Healey told a press conference earlier:
This is a now, a once-in-a-generation opportunity, the chance to deepen further that military, industry and nation partnership between our two countries.
So we have, today, signed an agreement, a declaration that we will work now to forge a deep, ambitious new defence agreement and we’ll do that by the summer.
Mr Healey also said that Norway and the UK will “step up further” the support to Ukraine, PA Media reports.
He later added:
We’ve said as two European nations that we will step up further the support we give to Ukraine. Ukraine is still fighting. We must keep them in the fight. We must try and keep them strong to secure that peace for the long-term.
Ed Davey: Farage 'sounds like like a spokeman for Trump'
Commenting on Nigel Farage’s response to Donald Trump calling President Zelenskyy a “dictator”, Liberal Democrat leader Ed Davey said on X:
So Nigel Farage has chosen to explain away Trump’s outrageous remarks about President Zelensky instead of doing the right thing and condemning them. Deeply disappointing but not at all surprising.
He sounds like a spokesman for Trump. He certainly doesn’t speak for Britain.
Farage criticises media over issue of UK suspending elections during wartime
Nigel Farage has attacked people suggesting that the UK did not hold elections during the second world war, and said that it was “about time the British media woke up to the truth of that.”
Put to him on GB News that his suggestion Ukraine have a timeline for elections during wartime contradicted the UK’s own wartime history of suspending them, Farage disputed the claim that there was no general election during the second world war.
The 1945 United Kingdom general election was held on 5 July 1945, 58 days after victory in Europe was declared on VE-day in May 1945, but prior to the surrender of the Japanese in the Pacific theatre of war.
Speaking from Washington, the MP for Clacton told viewers back in the UK:
As you well know, I’m a keen student of history, so let’s get this on the record, very clearly, the United Kingdom held a general election during world war two in the summer of 1945. We were still at war with Japan …. the nuclear bomb had not been dropped. There were British soldiers dying in large numbers every single day in Japanese camps. There was vicious fighting going on.
Farage was interrupted by a presenter interjecting with “there was peace in Europe,” to which Farage replied:
We were at war. World war two was still going on. So just as a matter of historical fact, I think it’s about time the British media woke up to the truth of that.
The UK went from November 1935 to July 1945 without an election, and during the first world war period went from December 1910 to December 1918 without a general election.
Farage compares cancellation of local elections in England to situation in Ukraine
The leader of Reform UK has compared the cancellation of local elections in England to the situation in Ukraine in an attempt to explain why Donald Trump has labelled Ukraine’s president Volodymyr Zelenskyy a “dictator”.
Having said that Trump’s words should be taken “seriously” but not “literally”, Nigel Farage said “Let’s be clear, Zelensky is not a dictator, but, but it’s only right and proper that Ukrainians have a timeline for elections.”
Speaking to GB News from Washington, the MP for Clacton then continued:
I mean, after all, I recently said that I thought Keir Starmer was behaving like a dictator because he’s cancelled the vote of five-and-a-half million people in local elections on 1 May. So no, he’s not a dictator, but there needs to be a timeline so that the Ukrainian people can vote on a peace deal.
Ukrainian martial law, which the country has been under since Vladimir Putin launched a full-scale invasion in February 2022, prevents elections taking place. It is unclear how Ukraine, during wartime, would manage the practicality of allowing a large number of refugees to vote from overseas, or administrate elections in the four regions which Russia has claimed to annex and partially occupies.
Farage said “I’m not suggesting Ukraine has an election tomorrow. But once we see the shape of a peace deal, then of course there should be an election.”
Local elections in nine areas of England have been delayed while Labour devolution reform causes reorganisation from two-tier council areas into authorities with regional mayors. At the time the election suspension was announced Angela Rayner said the government was not in the business of holding elections for local councils that would no longer exist, as it would be a waste of taxpayer money.
Updated
Farage: 'Zelenskyy is not a dictator' but 'only right and proper Ukrainians have a timeline for election'
Reform UK leader Nigel Farage has broken his silence on Donald Trump’s comments that Volodymyr Zelenskyy, saying “Let’s be clear, Zelenskyy is not a dictator, but it’s only right and proper that Ukrainians have a timeline for elections.”
Speaking from Washington to GB News, the MP for Clacton explained the delay in commenting was down to him being on a plane to the US, saying:
You should always take everything Donald Trump says seriously. You shouldn’t always take things that Donald Trump says absolutely literally. And I think that applies very much in this case.
There’s a lot of bad blood between president Trump and previous Ukrainian leaders. You know, the impeachment that happened was all because of a relationship between the Ukrainian government and the Biden family. So let’s be clear. Zelensky is not a dictator, but, but it’s only right and proper that Ukrainians have a timeline for elections.
Trump’s first impeachment was moved after he was accused of “a betrayal of his oath of office, a betrayal of our national security and betrayal of the integrity of our elections,” by pressuring Zelenskyy to state in public an investigation was being opened against Joe Biden in the run-up to the US election, which Trump repeatedly disputed he lost.
Defence secretary Healey: UK and Norway are negotiating new defence pact
The UK and Norway have started negotiations on a new defence pact aimed at what the countries perceive as a threat from Russia in the Arctic.
Defence secretary John Healey and his counterpart, Tore Sandvik, started the talks as they met at Norwegian Joint Headquarters, PA Media reports.
PA is carrying some pre-released quotes attributed to Healey, which were embargoed until 13.45. In them, the defence secretary, who earlier this week announced a significant reform of the Ministry of Defence and armed forces in the UK, said:
Kickstarting work on a deep, ambitious new defence agreement with Norway shows the UK promise to step up on European security in action.
Norway remains one of the UK’s most important allies. We will create a new era of defence partnership to bring us closer than ever before as we tackle increasing threats, strengthen Nato, and boost our security in the high north.
Earlier today both Andy Burnham and Ed Davey were among those asking why Reform UK MPs had been so silent on social media about recent developments between Donald Trump and Volodymyr Zelenskyy, with the US president calling the Ukrainian president a “dictator” causing a diplomat rift between the US and Europe. Zelenskyy has responded by saying Trump lives in a “disinformation bubble.”
The Reform MP for Great Yarmouth, Rupert Lowe, has just posted to social media. He said “Zelensky is not perfect, but he is not a dictator. Suspending elections, with the aim to hold a vote as soon as possible, during a war the Ukrainians did not start is fair. Trump is right – this cannot go on for ever. We need a long-term settlement tolerable to all involved.”
Carla Denyer, the co-leader of the Green party of England and Wales, has also spoken. She said “Trump sank to new depths with his tirade of disinformation about President Zelenskyy. Ed Davey is right, all of the UK must stand firmly with Ukraine against Trump’s dangerous propaganda, taken direct from Putin’s playbook.”
Updated
Former chair of the defence select committee Tobias Ellwood has warned the Britain risks being in direct conflict with Russia within five years, and said that current discussions about possible peace in Ukraine had descended into what he called “foghorn diplomacy” and that US president Donald Trump’s positioning had taken “everybody by surprise.”
Speaking on GB News, the former Conservative MP said:
I’m really sorry to see that the focus on Ukraine has escalated to this public level of so-called foghorn diplomacy. I attended the US inauguration, and many there, and indeed here, I think welcome Trump’s return to the White House, knowing he’d shake things up a little bit, not least in Ukraine and Gaza. Everyone willing to give Trump some latitude, given his very different style of doing business.
But the extent to which he’s been willing to court the enemy, to parrot the very words that Putin uses to blame Zelenskyy for the war, calling Zelenskyy, not Putin, a dictator. On top of which he’s ruling out any future Nato involvement in Ukraine’s long-term security, and dialling back a US military footprint in Europe, it’s taken everybody by surprise.
As well as his moves over Ukraine, in recent weeks Trump has announced a plan for the US to seize the territory of the Gaza Strip and “own” it, forcibly displacing the Palestinian population. During his election campaign, Trump said he would end the war in Ukraine saying “I’ll have that done. I’ll have that done in 24 hours.”
Ellwood said:
Let’s not forget that Vladimir Putin was in a very poor place just a week ago. His economy is heading for recession. The gruelling war that he’s paid a heavy price for with over 800,000 casualties was beginning to damage him politically, and now he’s been thrown a lifeline by America.
This will have huge repercussions for European security, because Putin, who’s increasingly backed by China, is now able to rebuild and fight another day, which he will.
And it’s clear to me that Trump’s view of Europe, that we must try and correct, is currently not one of a friend and an ally, but purely contractual, even as a competitor. That’s Trump’s approach. It’s always been about the deal.
He continued by saying “The world’s getting more dangerous, not less. Putin is on the advance. He wants to go back to Ukraine, get the rest of it and move further west as well. And I’m sorry to say this but, we are likely to be in some form of conflict. Conflict will come to us in the next five years or so, unless we sort Russia out now.”
The former soldier, who was MP for Bournemouth East from 2005 to 2024, also backed the return of a form of national service, saying that critics often misunderstood what was intended when people use the phrase.
He told viewers:
When you mention national service, you’ve got these ideas of the Carry On movies or sending 18-year-olds to the front line. That’s not what it’s all about.
This is about our ability to improve the nation’s security readiness, developing a latent level of resilience, right across the board. Yes, in the army, navy and air force, but in these other areas, the coast guard, the ambulance, fire service, mountain rescue, the defence industry, and particularly cyberskills, AI skills, air traffic control.
It is basically everybody doing a skill set they learn for a number of months, which can be tapped into at a later date, if required, if a crisis emerges.
Council tax rises of almost 20 per cent needed in Scotland to keep pace with England
Local authorities in Scotland will need to increase council tax bills by almost a fifth if they are to keep pace with increases to local government funding in England, a thinktank has found.
A report from the Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS) noted “core spending power” for local government and schools in England is set to increase by 7.4% in real-terms between 2023-24 and 2025-26.
With schools in Scotland funded by local councils, the IFS said: “To match this, Scottish councils would need to increase their council tax by an average of 18-19%.”
After council tax charges were frozen by the Scottish government for 2024-25, East Lothian council has already voted to increase bills for its residents by 10% in 2025-26 - with other local authorities expected to impose similar rises, PA Media reports.
David Phillips, associate director at the IFS, said:
If you look at the funding the Scottish government is providing to councils in Scotland and you compare that to what is being provided in England, the increases in England over the last two years, the core funding from the Scottish government isn’t keeping pace with what has been happening in England in the last two years.
Updated
Liberal Democrat leader Ed Davey is continuing to question the absence of comment on Ukraine from senior leadership in Reform UK in recent days.[see 10.30]
In a post on social media Davey said:
There’s a rumour that Nigel Farage is keeping his head down because he’s off to a Trump cheerleading conference over the weekend. I’m afraid I’m being proved right - Farage is far more interested in Trump’s success than British security. He is a bootlicker and a plastic patriot.
Defence secretary John Healey spent Thursday morning holding bilateral talks with Norwegian defence minister Tore Sandvik deep within a mountainside fortress.
Healey and his counterpart held their discussion at Norwegian Joint Headquarters, the command centre for Norway’s military, which is tunnelled into the side of a mountain near the town of Bodø in the north of the Scandinavian country.
They discussed shared security priorities, including Ukraine and defending the high north from Russia, PA Media reports.
Culture secretary Lisa Nandy says she will be “discussing” a Gaza documentary with the BBC after it emerged the film’s narrator was the son of a Hamas deputy minister.
Gaza: How To Survive A War Zone, which aired on Monday on BBC Two, is narrated by 13-year-old Abdullah Al-Yazouri, who speaks about what life is like in the territory amid the war between Israel and Hamas.
It later emerged that he is the son of Ayman Alyazouri, who has worked as Hamas’s deputy minister of agriculture.
The BBC apologised “for the omission of that detail from the original film”, and has edited the programme.
When asked about the controversy, Nandy told LBC: “It’s something that I will be discussing with them, particularly around the way in which they sourced the people who were featured in the programme.
“These things are difficult and I do want to acknowledge that for the BBC, they take more care than most broadcasters in terms of the way that they try to portray these things.
“They’ve been attacked for being too pro-Gaza. They’ve been attacked for being anti-Gaza.
“But it is absolutely essential that we get this right.”
She added that she is “about to have” a discussion with the BBC about its reporting guidelines, after a consultation which ended last year.
Updated
We have more figures from the NHS which shows the number of number of people in hospital in England with norovirus has jumped sharply to reach a new high for this winter.
An average of 1,160 hospital beds were filled each day last week by patients with diarrhoea and vomiting or norovirus-like symptoms, up 22% from 948 the previous week.
Norovirus levels also remain higher than at this point 12 months ago, when an average of 509 beds were filled with patients with symptoms, and also two years ago (629 patients), PA Media reports.
Here are details from the NHS situation report which shows that 29.1% of patients arriving by ambulance at hospitals in England last week waited at least 30 minutes to be handed over to A&E teams, up from 27.9% in the previous week, PA Media reports.
The figure stood as high as 42.2% at the start of the year.
Some 9.6% of ambulance handovers last week were delayed by more than an hour, up week-on-week from 9.1%, but well below the peak of 21.3% in early January.
Meanwhile, an average of 13,767 hospital beds per day were filled last week in England with patients who were fit to be discharged.
This is down from 14,087 the previous week, which was the highest number so far this winter.
On average, 41% of patients ready to leave hospital last week were actually discharged each day.
Kiran Stacey is a political correspondent for the Guardian based in Westminster
The former head of the Foreign Office has warned Rachel Reeves not to cut Britain’s international aid spending, amid signs the chancellor is willing to raid the development budget to help pay for higher defence spending.
Simon McDonald, the former lead civil servant at the Foreign Office, said it would damage Britain’s global reputation if Reeves chose to reduce aid as she looks for savings across Whitehall in this year’s spending review.
Government sources have told the Guardian the aid budget is one of a number of areas being eyed up for savings, with the chancellor demanding that ministers justify every item of government spending.
But with the US president, Donald Trump, having recently frozen the US aid programme, McDonald warned such a move would have serious implications for the world’s poorest people.
He told the Guardian: “At times of financial need, development assistance is an easy target for trimming because international assistance is not generally voters’ priority.
“I hope the Treasury is not sharpening its knife for further cuts: not only has the UK’s international reputation taken a knock from the 2020 cut, the international need for such help is greater than ever with the slashing of USAid.”
Read more of Kiran Stacey’s exclusive report here: Former Foreign Office head warns Reeves not to cut international aid
Liberal Democrat MSP for Shetland Beatrice Wishart has taken the “difficult decision” not to stand in next year’s Holyrood election, PA Media reports. 69-year-old Wishart said it has been an “honour and a privilege” to represent the islands in Holyrood, and vowed to “continue to work tirelessly for all constituents.”
Two of the Green Party of England and Wales MPs in Westminster have also made remarks about Donald Trump’s comments on Ukraine’s president Zelenskyy this morning.
Ellie Chowns, MP for North Herefordshire, said “Trump’s comments become more delusional and dangerous by the day. It’s more vital than ever that the UK government speaks truth to power, stands up for British values and interests, and challenges Trump’s tsunami of disinformation.”
Siân Berry, the Brighton Pavillion MP, alluding to comments made yesterday by disgraced former prime minister Boris Johnson yesterday, said “Real danger comes from brushing off Trump’s lie.”
Meanwhile Liberal Democrat leader Ed Davey has joined mayor of Greater Manchester Andy Burnham [see 9.05am] in questioning the absence of comment on Ukraine from senior leadership in Reform UK. Davey posted to social media to say “You seem unusually quiet there Nigel Farage, any thoughts?”
The Politics Weekly podcast this week features John Harris hearing from the Guardian’s diplomatic editor Patrick Wintour and columnist Gaby Hinsliff about what a resolution could look like in Ukraine, and the role that the UK may have to play in it. You can listen to it here.
Graeme Wearden has some worrying news for chancellor Rachel Reeves here:
Confidence among UK consumers has dropped off a cliff since last summer, as people – particularly women – grow more worried about the state of the economy, and their own finances.
A new survey from the British Retail Consortium (BRC) and Opinium has found that the public’s expectations for the economy worsened for a fifth month running in February.
Households are also gloomier about their own personal finances, as they anticipate further price rises in the shops – as retailers pass on higher taxes.
February’s drop in confidence continues a decline that started last July, when the Labour party won the general election – and swiftly began warning about ‘tough choices’ and ‘painful decisions’ to fix the country’s finances.
You can read more of Graeme Weardon’s live business coverage here: UK consumer confidence sinks to new low
Updated
In some business news, the owner of British Gas has reported its annual profits have dropped by a third. The supplier’s parent company, Centrica, reported adjusted earnings of £2.3bn for last year, down by a third from 2023 when its profits reached £3.5bn. Energy correspondent Jillian Ambrose has the details …
The co-leader of the Green party of England and Wales Carla Denyer has reiterated the party’s call for the imposition of rent controls.
Reacting to a report claiming that average UK private rents increased by 8.7% over the last year, Denyer posted on social media to say:
Yet another unsustainable rise in rents – time for the government to put a stop to rip off rents and stop landlords treating tenants as cash cows. Rent controls are long overdue and are badly needed to give all renters a home they can afford.
Back on the subject of Ukraine for a second, shadow foreign secretary Priti Patel has posted a clip of her interview on Sky News this morning to social media, and reiterated the message she was giving, saying:
For three years president Zelenskyy has led Ukraine in standing up to Putin’s aggression and he is fighting for sovereignty, freedom and our values. The UK must provide leadership on defence spending increasing and work with our European and Nato allies to step up on defence and security.
As well as appearing on the airwaves this morning to promote Labour’s £270m Arts Everywhere fund, culture secretary Lisa Nandy also supplied some quotes for the press release accompanying the launch.
She said:
Arts and culture help us understand the world we live in, they shape and define society and are enjoyed by people in every part of our country. They are the building blocks of our world-leading creative industries and make a huge contribution towards boosting growth and breaking down barriers to opportunities for young people to learn the creative skills they need to succeed.
The funding we are announcing today will allow the arts to continue to flourish across Britain, creating good jobs and growth by fixing the foundations in our cultural venues, museums, libraries and heritage institutions [and] will ensure that arts and cultural institutions truly are for everyone, everywhere.
Deputy prime minister Angela Rayner is also quoted in the release, saying that the increased funding for cultural projects means “more tourism, more growth and more money in people’s pockets.”
Nandy: previous Tory government policy to slash arts funding was 'economic madness'
Culture secretary Lisa Nandy made a passionate defence of the value of the arts in the UK’s cultural and economic life as she launched a new Labour government initiative, a £270m Arts Everywhere fund for arts venues, museums, libraries and the heritage sector.
Speaking on the BBC Radio 4 Today programme, Nandy was challenged that a new European security framework and pressure for increased defence spending was liable to take chunks out of her budget in the near future. She said:
Look, we’ve had a decade where funding to the arts, funding for communities has been slashed. We’ve seen culture erased from our classrooms and our communities. It’s economic madness.
This is one of the fastest growing industries in the UK – film, music, literature, TV. We export them all over the world. We’ve got countries clamouring to invest here in the UK. Some of the biggest streamers in the world, who want to invest more in the UK, but it takes support from the government
That’s why today, on the 60th anniversary of Jenny Lee’s seminal arts white paper, we’re launching the Arts Everywhere fund.
Too many people have seen arts and culture erased from their communities and it’s costing this country dear.
That’s why this government is taking a very different approach from the last, and we don’t accept that keeping our country safe, and enabling our country to thrive and grow our economy is a zero sum game.
Updated
Speaking on LBC radio, culture secretary Lisa Nandy has said the prime minister will speak with the US president about ensuring “a role for Europe” in the end to the war in Ukraine.
PA Media reports she told listeners:
Last time president Trump was in office, Keir and I met with senior members of the Trump administration and found them to be incredibly pragmatic in the way they go about wanting to solve problems, do deals and get outcomes.
That is the mantra that the president has pushed since the moment he was president-elect – he wants to get outcomes, he wants to see things change, and he’s been absolutely clear that he wants to see a solution in Ukraine.
We’ve been clear in turn that there can be no solution without Ukraine at the table. We’ve been clear that there must be a role for Europe.
And I think that is a view that is shared by the Trump administration, and that’s the conversation that the prime minister will be having next week when he travels to the US.”
Lisa Nandy has said “we’re getting way ahead of ourselves” when questioned about the details of any British troop deployment to Ukraine as part of a peacekeeping mission.
Asked whether troops would be deployed in Ukraine in the teeth of Russian opposition, she told listeners of the BBC Radio 4 Today programme:
We’re absolutely committed to supporting Ukraine, not just to win the war, but to win the peace as well. And that is the position of the US as well. Marco Rubio, the US secretary of state, said recently nothing is off the table.
I think we’re getting way ahead of ourselves here. What the prime minister is is seeking to achieve with his conversations with the European Union, conversations with President Trump and conversations with President Zelenskyy, is to bring all parties around the table to negotiate a solution to this.
Shadow foreign secretary Priti Patel was also asked about the prospect of British troops in Ukraine during her media appearances. She told Sky News “we would work constructively with the government” adding “I think we need to understand more detail.”
Patel appeared to concur with Nandy’s position that it was too early to realistically comment on any plans, saying “We’re not at that stage yet, so it’s far too premature, but we’d need to understand the details and the substance. And, you know, these are fair points to fly right now in terms of suggestions. But I think at this stage, it’s far too premature. Of course, we will happily be part of those discussions and conversations with the Labour government here.”
Nandy: important to continue dialogue with Russia and that Russia 'hears what the world believes'
Culture secretary Lisa Nandy was asked on the BBC Radio 4 Today if she was concerned by comments from the Russian ambassador to the UK that the US is “for the first time” listening to Moscow’s point of view over the invasion of Ukraine.
Nandy said she was not, saying “it doesn’t worry me”. She continued:
I think it’s important that we maintain a dialogue with Russia, and I think it’s important that Russia hears what the world believes, and certainly across Europe.
And with recent comments by the US secretary of state, Marco Rubio, it’s very clear that we believe that Russia has to end this invasion in Ukraine. It’s important that we stick together on this. And I think it would be tempting for me to come on your show and commentate on the latest interventions, but that is never the way that you achieve peace.
Andy Burnham has attacked the silence of senior figures in Reform UK on Ukraine in recent days.
In a post to social media, the mayor of Greater Manchester said:
Normally you can’t escape Reform UK MPs gobbing off on here but interesting, isn’t it, how silent they are about their friend’s campaign to undermine Volodymyr Zelenskyy and Ukraine. Just when you need them to use some influence to protect British interests, they don’t.
Patel: Trump 'wrong' to call Zelenskyy a dictator and 'there are no clear solutions right now' to conflict
Shadow foreign secretary Priti Patel told viewers of Sky News this morning that she could not comment on the “motivation” of Donald Trump in criticising Volodymyr Zelenskyy, but said that Trump was “wrong”.
Ask what she made of the comments, Patel said:
First of all, that’s wrong. President Zelenskyy is not a dictator. Let’s just put some context of this. For three years – the third anniversary of the conflict is on Monday – for three years he has led his nation in terms of this conflict, standing up to Putin, Putin’s aggression, and the appalling conduct that we’ve seen.
[Zelenskyy] is fighting for sovereignty and the freedom of his country. And this is a significant conflict in our neighbourhood, effectively on European soil, and this is the most brutal conflict that we’ve seen in Europe since, clearly, the second world war. So here’s a man that’s fighting for sovereignty, freedom, and actually standing up for the rule of law, and many of the values that we all hold very dearly.
Asked “Why is president Trump saying that, do you think?” Patel replied “We don’t know. And you know, I don’t think I could comment on his motivation.”
Patel said Trump had been making some consistent points about European defence spending, and she anticipated that the presence of the US envoy to Ukraine Keith Kellogg in Kyiv would “actually help inform the White House going forward, [and] potentially try and inform some of the debates and discussions.”
She continued:
I think I said at the weekend too that there is a lot of chatter, there’s a lot of noise. There are no clear solutions right now.
And I think, you know, I say this not just as a member of the Conservative frontbench, but actually as a British politician, having led the support for Ukraine, this is why we must really be quite strong all over again in our support for greater defence and military spending and capability.
In terms of working with the government, my party had a plan to increase defence spending. We will be very keen to work with the government on that. But the macro point here is to show some firm and strong leadership with our European allies and within Nato to say that, look, war in Europe is not acceptable.
Nandy: 'heat' needs to be taken out of public conversations about Ukraine peace prospects
Lisa Nandy has urged for the “heat” to be taken out of public conversations about peace proposals to end the war caused by Russia’s invasion of Ukraine after a day of heated exchanges between US president Donald Trump and Ukraine’s president Volodymyr Zelenskyy.
Speaking on the BBC Radio 4 Today programme, the culture secretary said:
I think we need to take the heat down from what has become a very heated conversation in public over recent days. That’s what the prime minister has been doing, meeting with European leaders, speaking to President Zelenskyy. Next week, he’ll travel to the US to meet with President Trump.
Downing Street said that Keir Starmer spoke to Zelenskyy last night to reassure him that the UK saw him as Ukraine’s democratically elected leader, and not a “dictator”, as Trump had claimed.
Nandy continued, in an apparent reference to the negotiations that led to the Good Friday agreement, by saying:
The truth is that if we want a solution to what is happening in Ukraine –and we absolutely do, because it’s in British interests to do so, and it’s the right thing to do – then we know in our country from the experience of dealing with very difficult matters on our own shores, that the only way that you reach a solution is to bring all parties around the table, to take the heat down, to have cool heads, and to bring people together for a negotiated solution.
Justin Webb repeatedly questioned Nandy on whether the UK government agreed with Trump’s wording or not, but she diplomatically refused to be drawn in to an outright direct criticism while saying she was clear that the UK has a different view to the US president. She said:
We’ve got our own view as the UK. And our view is that the US matters, Ukraine must be involved in negotiations about Ukraine’s own future, and that Europe matters as well.
And we need to make sure with all parties around the table that our alliance doesn’t fracture. We’re absolutely committed to Nato. We have to hold that coalition together. We have got a real threat here in Vladimir Putin. We have got to work together with our allies in order to make sure that we don’t just win the war and win the peace in Ukraine, but we also make sure that we don’t see the like of this happening again.
Webb put it to Nandy that “would it not be reasonable for the prime minister to publicly contradict” Trump on claims Zelenskyy was a “dictator” who had done “a bad job”, and she replied:
The prime minister has made his own view clear. He spoke to president Zelenskyy in the last few days and made clear that he understands, first of all, that he is an elected leader, and we consider him in the United Kingdom to be a legitimate leader.
We do not consider president Zelenskyy to be a dictator. He was elected by the people of Ukraine. And the reason that there haven’t been elections is because of Russian aggression, and that is something that is out with Ukrainian control. We stand with Ukraine, and our belief in that, our support for Ukraine is unshakable.
Starmer held overnight call to give support to 'democratically elected' president Zelenskyy
Keir Starmer has spoken to Volodymyr Zelenskyy to express support for him “as Ukraine’s democratically elected leader” after Donald Trump claimed Ukraine’s president was a “dictator”
A Downing Street spokesperson said:
The prime minister spoke to President Zelenskyy this evening and stressed the need for everyone to work together. The prime minister expressed his support for President Zelenskyy as Ukraine’s democratically elected leader and said that it was perfectly reasonable to suspend elections during war time as the UK did during the second world war.
Ukraine had been scheduled to hold elections in 2024, but they were cancelled due to the full-scale Russian invasion of the country launched by Vladimir Putin nearly three years ago in late February 2022.
Other senior political figures have also reacted to the US president’s comments. Conservative opposition leader Kemi Badenoch said Zelenskyy was “the democratically elected leader of Ukraine who bravely stood up to Putin’s illegal invasion”. Liberal Democrat leader Ed Davey said Trump’s comments “must be where the line is drawn”
Welcome and opening summary …
Good morning, and welcome to our rolling coverage of UK politics for Thursday. Here are the headlines …
Keir Starmer has spoken to Volodymyr Zelenskyy to express support for him “as Ukraine’s democratically elected leader” after US president Donald Trump claimed Ukraine’s president was a “dictator”
On Thursday morning minister Lisa Nandy said that the heat needed to be taken out public discussions about any peace deal in Ukraine
Shadow foreign secretary Priti Patel said on Thursday that she could not comment on the motivation behind Trump’s attack on Zelenskyy and that “there are no clear solutions right now”, offering tentative Conservative support to any plans to put British troops on the ground in Ukraine
The Labour government has announced a £270m Arts Everywhere fund for arts venues, museums, libraries and the heritage sector. Chancellor Rachel Reeves and Nandy are expected to make appearances today to promote the programme
Plans by the Labour government to prevent refugees who arrive in the UK on a small boat, lorry or via other so-called “irregular” means from becoming a British citizen are facing their first legal challenge
Defence secretary John Healey is in Norway, and foreign secretary David Lammy is at a G20 ministerial meeting in South Africa
It is Martin Belam with you again today. You can reach me at martin.belam@theguardian.com. I do find it useful if you let me know if you spot my inevitable typos, errors or omissions.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e2409/e240998c984b3421aeae422fede4d15586f24dd1" alt=""